Tushy is the bigger, earlier Mad Cheddar anal flagship; Tushy Raw is the later sibling built around a more specific, mysterious-man-and-colorful-props concept.
They are related, not random competitors: both are owned by Mad Cheddar. The available information treats them as separate sites, so don’t assume one automatically includes the other unless the current signup offer says so.
The short answer
Pick Tushy if you want the safer all-around choice: a more developed library, polished 4K-style production, varied models, and weekly exclusive anal scenes. Pick Tushy Raw if the appeal is the theme itself: a tighter, stranger, more stylized sibling with its own mysterious-man setup and prop-heavy flavor.
| Dimension | Tushy | Tushy Raw |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | Mad Cheddar site | Mad Cheddar sibling |
| Launch era | Launched in 2015 | Launched in 2018 |
| Content focus | Anal scenes | Anal scenes |
| Tone | Polished and cinematic | More themed and mysterious |
| Signature hook | Varied models and scenes | Mysterious man, colorful props |
| Video quality | HD and Ultra HD | HD and Ultra HD |
| Update rhythm | Weekly exclusives | Weekly updates |
| Library size | More developed catalog | Newer, narrower concept |
Tushy
Tushy is the cleaner default pick because it has had more time to build out a proper premium library. It launched in 2015, which gives it the edge on depth, variety, and that “I can browse for a while and still find something new” feeling.
The site’s lane is cinematic anal content with a glossy, curated finish. Our review notes Tushy’s 8.3/10 score, weekly exclusives, and strong 4K-style presentation, while also flagging download caps as the one thing that keeps it from feeling completely untouchable.
If you want a polished anal site with a bigger bench of models and scenes, Tushy is the one that makes the most sense first.
Pros
- More developed library since 2015
- Cinematic HD and Ultra HD production
- Weekly exclusives with varied models
Cons
- More polished than raw-themed
- Download caps noted in our review
Tushy Raw
Tushy Raw is not just “more Tushy.” It launched later, in 2018, and its identity is built around a more distinctive setup: a mysterious man, colorful props, and a narrower visual concept wrapped around anal scenes.
That makes Tushy Raw the more mood-specific pick. It still sits in the same Mad Cheddar family and offers HD and Ultra HD content with weekly updates, but its main selling point is the concept rather than sheer catalog breadth.
Choose Tushy Raw when you already know that themed, prop-driven presentation is what gets your attention. If you mostly want range and volume, Tushy has the stronger base.
Pros
- Distinct mysterious-man setup
- Colorful prop-driven theme
- Weekly updates in HD and Ultra HD
Cons
- Newer and less developed than Tushy
- More specific concept may not suit everyone
Which should you get?
Get Tushy first. It is the better default in 2026 because it has the more developed library, the broader model and scene variety, and the polished premium feel most guys expect when they are choosing an anal-focused site.
Pick Tushy Raw instead if the specific theme is the whole attraction for you. They are siblings under Mad Cheddar, but based on the available information, you should treat them as separate choices unless the current offer clearly bundles access.
